1. Gaza is Always Under Siege
In other
words, even on the best of days, when Israel is not bombing Gaza , it is largely responsible for holding 1.7
million people captive in miserable conditions. According to international law,
by maintaining “effective
control” of Gaza , Israel still meets the definition of
occupying power. This status has been
affirmed by the Red Cross, Amnesty International, the U.N., and the U.S. State
Department, among
others.
2. Asymmetry
of Power
This
“conflict” cannot be called a war. This is an assault by one of the most
advanced militaries in the world with
the full backing, and weaponry, of the U.S. , the sole world super power. By
every measure, including
fatalities, fatalities of civilians, injuries, and destruction of
infrastructure, the disproportionate impact on Gaza is clear. While there is no excuse
for attacks on civilians, whether in Israel or in the U.S. , the threat from Gaza to Israel and Israelis is no comparison to
the harm being inflicted on Gaza .
3. Collective
Punishment
4. Who
Started The Fighting?
While the
predominant narrative in the media tells a story about Israel being forced to defend itself, the truth
is that Israel has repeatedly broken truces with
Hamas, including in this latest escalation.
Until
November of this year, one Israeli had been killed by fire from Gaza in 2012, while 78 Palestinians had been
killed by Israeli attacks.
On November
8th, five days before coverage of this latest round began, a 12 year old boy in
Gaza was killed by
Israeli soldiers, which drew a response from militants in Gaza . Although three more civilians,
including two children, were killed by Israeli fire during the course of
several exchanges between
November 8th and 11th, Palestinian militant factions agreed to a truce on
November 11th.
Most
disturbingly, after two days of calm, Israel then assassinated Ahmed Jabari, the
head of Hamas’s military
wing, and a relative moderate who, it is claimed by independent Israeli
negotiator Gershom Baskin, had
just two hours before received a proposal for a long-term truce that had been
painstakingly developed
by Israelis and Hamas officials.
5. Media
Distortions
In U.S. publications, especially, there are
routine referrals to Israeli “surgical” or “pinpoint” strikes and to
“targeted assassinations.” These terms imply a precision that does not exist,
and that have resulted in
extensive civilian casualties.
News
reports often refer to the “cycle of violence” as if both sides have equal
power and are equally responsible
for the violence. The context of the continuing blockade of Gaza and the enormous disparities in fire
power and overall control are not mentioned.
Politicians,
in the U.S. and Israel , constantly claim that Israel “has the right to defend itself”
which is dutifully
repeated in news reports. If this is true, does Gaza have the right to defend itself
from Israeli attack in
the same manner? There is a clear double-standard at work.
6. U.S. Role
Elbit U.S.A. , to name a few, purchases made
possible by U.S. military aid to Israel . In other words, U.S. taxpayers are funding the Israeli
attack on Gaza .
7. No
Military Solution
Sources:
www.imeu.net; “Ten Things You Need to Know About Gaza” by Mehdi Hasan
(http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/mehdi-hasan/gaza-10-things-you-need-to-know_b_2139356.html);
Palestinian
Centre for
Human Rights (www.pchr.org)
For more
information go to www.JVP.org
Jewish
Voice for Peace • 1611 Telegraph Avenue, Suite 550 , Oakland , CA 94612 • 510.465.1777
No comments:
Post a Comment